Fred and Yasser’s Film Club: Week Four, Part Two – ‘High Noon’ (1952)

Posted on Updated on

The Premise
Film fanatics and friends
 Fred Sullivan and Yasser Akram are on a mission to watch 25 of one another’s favourite movies. Each week they will watch one movie each and then get together to discuss what they have seen. So far, they have visited ChinaFranceMoroccoKazakhstan, the English countryside and the human soul itself, and it’s all been here for you to enjoy.

Earlier this week, the boy’s discussed ‘War Horse‘, which was Yasser’s choice for Fred. Now it’s Fred’s pick and he’s gone for an Oscar-winning Western.

You can read the entires from previous week by checking out the archives on the left of the screen.

You can also access the lists so far by clicking here for Fred’s and here for Yasser’s.

Yasser: Let’s talk about ‘High Noon’

‘High Noon’
1952 – USA
Director: Fred Zinnemann
Starring: Gary Cooper, Grace Kelly, Thomas Mitchell, Katy Juardo, Lloyd Bridges

Fred: Okay. Your text message (“High Noon is a Western!! Oh dear…“) didn’t fill me with hope.

YA: Westerns, like, it’s firmly within me that I generally detest that shit.

FS: I’m surprised. I would have thought they would be up your street.

YA: Really? What made you think that?

FS: One – they are generally quite action packed; Two – Clint Eastwood strikes me as the kind of star you would appreciate; Three – …. the hats.

YA: (laughs) Hats

FS: (laughs) I couldn’t think of a third.

YA: Clint Eastwood is wonderful. I appreciate his acting and directing.

FS: …but…

YA: I just never got in to it. I remember my dad ALWAYS watching ‘The Magnificent Seven‘ and forcing me to watch them.

FS: Nothing feels fun if you are forced to do it, like all the great books you hate forever because you were made to read them at school.

YA: I had a basic portable handheld gameboy type thing with a ‘Back to the Future III‘ game on it. I liked that, but I was naughty once and me Mam hid it. She forgot where she hid it too and we soon moved house… loved that toy… I wonder if it’s still hidden?

FS: (laughs)

YA: Sorry, digressing. (laughs) I dunno. I’ve never been too into them. ‘Cowboys and Aliens‘ didn’t help either. I did love ‘Unforgiven‘ though.

FS: Surely ‘High Noon’ is more ‘Unforgiven’ than ‘Cowboys and Aliens’?

YA: See, last week you said “Grace Kelly“. I thought ‘great! A classy, city-based movie. Love and romance between a sassy woman and a city slicker.

FS: (laughs) Nope! I did think the title would have given it away as a Western.

YA: (laughs) Forgive me for thinking that Grace Kelly only did certain types of movies. I did think it was an odd name for a glamorous romance.

FS: She was surprisingly versatile in her short career.

YA: The tune was annoying in the movie.

FS: ‘Do Not Forsake Me, Oh My Darling’


FS: The thing is, if you already hate Westerns, is the music actually ruining it for you?

YA: Aside from the music and another, albeit small, niggle, the movie was surprisingly good.

FS: Oh good! Let’s take the niggle first, if we may.

YA: Gary Cooper was WAY too old for Grace Kelly. He looked like her Dad, man. I thought he was giving her away at the wedding.

FS: (laughs)

YA: Then they kissed and I felt like ‘bleugh’.

FS: It’s difficult when one of the screen’s great romantic idols gets old and ends up looking like Sid James chasing teenagers in a late ‘Carry On‘ film. He’s brilliant in the film though.

YA: He is good. I don’t think the supporting cast was any good.

FS: Really?

YA: Cooper carried most of it.

FS: He is the main man, but Lloyd Bridges, Katy Juardo and Thomas Mitchell all played their parts well I thought.

YA: Actually, Katy Juardo was good. The other two were too wishy-washy for me.

FS: Surely that was in keeping with their spineless characters.

YA: Cooper was like Rambo.

FS: (laughs) That’s not a parallel I’d ever have thought of, but go on…

YA: He was by himself for the most part. People around him letting him down. They keep him around and then fuck him over. Kinda like ‘Rambo II

FS: (laughs) I’ve never seen it.

FS: In week one, I said I felt ‘Fearless‘ was making a political statement and you didn’t agree.

YA: I said you watch too much news.

FS: Well this is a film categorically making one – and a very brave one at that.

YA: Care to elaborate?

FS: Hollywood in the early ’50s – Senator Joseph McCarthy and his committee tried to root out any person with communist affiliations or sympathies. They carried out ‘witch hunts’, calling people to testify and asking them to name names. Those who did were free to work on. Those who refused, remained silent, or were named saw their careers ruined. It’s probably one of the blackest periods in American history.

YA: (scratches head)

FS: Here is Will Kane (Gary Cooper), a man looking for the support of his friends and he finds none, so has to face the music alone. He’s symbolic of all those people who refused to name names. If Hollywood as a whole had stood up to McCarthy he’d have been powerless, but they didn’t.

YA: I don’t necessarily like politics, although it does affect the film industry.

FS: The writer of this movie, Carl Foreman, was one of those blacklisted. Isn’t it good that a few people were willing to put movies out there that condemned the whole thing?

YA: Yeah, I’m all about the rebel alliance.

FS: (laughs) Good man.

YA: Back to the on-screen events of ‘High Noon’. The BEST thing was that it was in real-time.

FS: It’s a nice little plot device.

YA: I’m finding that each of your movies have different elements to them so far. ‘Crimes and Misdemeanors‘ and its intertwining subplots, ‘Sleuth‘ was mano-e-mano, ‘Breathless‘ had the jump shot, and this one is in real-time.

FS: So what are you rating it?

YA: I didn’t hate it. I quite enjoyed it. I would give it 6/10. I thought the suspense towards the end was good. I liked how he’d hit rock bottom. I felt for him when both his wife and his ex were leaving together. Poor guy.

FS: 6/10 – I expected a 4 after that text message.

YA: So did I.

FS: (laughs) Just so you know… Cooper and Kelly were fucking in real life.

YA: OH WHAT! No no no no… no no no.

FS: I know. She also had Bing Crosby, Clark Gable, Ray Milland…

YA: Grace Kelly isn’t as classy as I once thought she was.

FS: (laughs) So, I have been looking forward to this week more than any other.

YA: Topsy Turvy. Is that one of those movies like ‘Memento‘ where is starts at the finish and ends at the beginning?

FS: I said there was one movie on my list I’d thought you would hate… ‘Topsy Turvy’ is it.

YA: Oh dear! (laughs) I hope you like East is East.

FS: I have seen it before, but 13 years ago when I had probably met zero Asian people in my life.

YA: Now you’re talking to the Asian sensation.

FS: Who’d have thought it?

YA: I dunno, man, but aint you glad it’s happened?

FS: Oh yes – it’s enriched my life.

Next week: Let’s party like it’s 1999 with ‘East is East’ and ‘Topsy Turvy’


3 thoughts on “Fred and Yasser’s Film Club: Week Four, Part Two – ‘High Noon’ (1952)

    […] High Noon […]

    […] needed that run time as it had more complex background to cover. I hesitate to use ‘High Noon‘ and ‘Bad Day at Black Rock‘ as examples, as I know you didn’t like them […]

    […] ‘Cinema Paradiso‘, ‘Wild Strawberries‘, ‘Topsy-Turvy‘, ‘High Noon‘, ‘Breathless‘ and ‘Crimes and Misdemeanors‘. Would never have […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s